Create a free account to save articles, track your reading, and ask questions in the forums.
"You can survive a bad market. You can survive a high interest rate. You cannot survive a bad tenant in a rental that only cash flows $200/month."
The biggest mistake new landlords make is letting excitement about a rental application cloud their judgment. A great-looking apartment goes under contract, the phone starts ringing, and suddenly you're approving someone because they seem "nice" and you want to fill the vacancy fast.
Nice doesn't pay rent. Consistency, verified income, and a clean track record pay rent. Here's how to build a screening process that finds great tenants and keeps you legally protected.
Setting Legal Screening Criteria (Before You List)
Before you take a single application, write down your screening criteria and apply them consistently to every applicant. This protects you legally. Standard criteria include:
Income
Monthly income ≥ 3× monthly rent
Credit score
Minimum 620–650 (you set this)
Rental history
No evictions in the past 5 years
Criminal background
Consistent with local law
Employment
Employed or verifiable income source
References
Positive from prior landlords
Post these criteria in your listing. Applicants who don't meet them self-select out — saving you both time.
The 5 Things You Must Check
Credit report
Pull a full credit report, not just a score. Look at payment history, collections, and bankruptcies. A 580 score with zero collections is different from a 580 with $14,000 in unpaid debt. Use a service like RentSpree, TransUnion SmartMove, or Cozy.
Income verification
Ask for the last two pay stubs AND the last two bank statements. Pay stubs can be faked — bank statements are much harder to forge. Look for the payroll deposits to match the pay stubs. Self-employed applicants should provide two years of tax returns.
Eviction history
Run a national eviction search. Court records are public and searchable. An eviction filing — even if dismissed — tells you a landlord took legal action. That's a serious flag worth exploring in your verification call.
Landlord references
Call the current AND previous landlord — not just the current one. A bad landlord may give a positive reference just to get rid of a problem tenant. The previous landlord has nothing to gain and will be more candid. Ask: 'Would you rent to them again?' Listen to the hesitation, not just the words.
Employment verification
Call the employer directly — look up the number yourself rather than using the one the applicant provides. Confirm position, start date, and income. If they're self-employed or have a non-traditional income source, require 6 months of bank statements minimum.
Red Flags to Watch For
Wants to move in immediately — extreme urgency often means they were just evicted
Offers to pay several months upfront to bypass the screening process
Hesitates or makes excuses when asked for standard documentation
Prior landlord won't answer, hangs up, or gives vague answers
Income from multiple jobs but none of them verifiable
Multiple addresses in the past 2 years without a clear explanation
Fair Housing: What You Cannot Do
The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, religion, sex, familial status, and disability. Many states add more protected classes. You cannot:
- Refuse to rent based on any protected characteristic
- Apply different standards to different applicants (charge one person more, require higher income from another)
- Ask questions about protected characteristics (family plans, country of origin, disability status)
- Advertise preferences that exclude protected classes
✅ How to stay compliant
Approve or deny based only on your written criteria, applied consistently. Document every decision. If you deny an applicant, send a written adverse action notice citing the specific criteria they didn't meet.
My Exact Screening Process
- 1.List the property with criteria clearly stated. Include minimum income, credit score, and no-eviction policy.
- 2.Send a pre-screening questionnaire to all inquiries. Ask about income, move-in date, and pets. This filters 40% of unqualified leads before an application.
- 3.Show the property. During the showing, be professional and consistent with every applicant.
- 4.Require a completed application with a $45–65 fee covering credit, background, and eviction checks.
- 5.Review: credit report, income docs, eviction history. If any are a hard no, send a written denial.
- 6.Call both the current landlord AND the previous landlord. This call is often the most valuable information you'll get.
- 7.Verify employment by calling the company's main number independently.
- 8.Approve or deny in writing. Keep all records for at least 3 years.
Sarah Chen
Buy-and-Hold Investor · 1,240 posts · REICommunity Contributor
Sarah self-manages 14 single-family rentals and has screened over 200 tenant applications. She developed a consistent screening process after one early eviction that cost her $8,400 and four months of lost rent.
Join the conversation
62 investors are already discussing this article. Share your experience or ask a question — free members get full access.