Create a free account to save articles, track your reading, and ask questions in the forums.
"If a deal is on Zillow and it's a good flip, there are 40 people looking at it. Your edge has to come from finding deals before they hit the market."
The math of house flipping only works when you buy right. "Buying right" means paying 65–75 cents on the dollar relative to after-repair value. Properties on the MLS are priced at retail or close to it — sellers have agents, market data, and competing buyers driving prices up.
Off-market deals come from motivated sellers who haven't listed yet, don't want the hassle of a traditional sale, or need speed more than they need top dollar. Here are the seven methods that experienced flippers actually use — ranked roughly by cost and effort.
Why MLS Deals Rarely Work for Flippers
It's not that MLS deals are impossible. Occasionally you'll find a bank-owned property or an estate sale priced aggressively. But the math is stacked against you:
- Listed properties attract retail buyers who don't need a margin — they're buying to live in it
- Agents are legally required to present all offers, so you're competing with every buyer in the market
- Properties that need significant work are often listed above your maximum allowable offer
- Inspection periods and standard timelines don't work in your favor against cash retail buyers
The 7 Off-Market Deal Sources
Drive neighborhoods looking for visually distressed properties — overgrown lawns, boarded windows, peeling paint, newspapers piled up. Note the address, skip-trace the owner's contact info, and mail or call them. This is how many full-time flippers got their first deal.
💡 Pro tip: Use the DealMachine app to log properties, run skip traces, and send direct mail all from your phone while driving.
Mail postcards or letters to targeted lists — absentee owners, tax-delinquent owners, inherited properties, probate, or owners who haven't refinanced in 15+ years. Response rates are 0.5–2%, but the deals that come in are often deeply motivated.
💡 Pro tip: Consistency is key. One mailing gets ignored. The same letter hitting the same address 4–6 times over a year is when calls come in.
Wholesalers find distressed deals and sell their contracts to investors for a fee ($5k–$20k+). The deal is already packaged — you just evaluate and close. The downside: everyone in the market gets the same email blast, so you need to move fast and know your ARVs cold.
💡 Pro tip: Build relationships with 3–5 consistent wholesalers in your market. The best deals often get a call before the email blast goes out.
When someone dies without a trust, their estate goes through probate — a public court process. The executor must often sell assets to pay debts. These motivated sellers want to close the estate quickly. Find probate filings at your county courthouse or online court records.
💡 Pro tip: Be respectful and patient. Executors are often grieving family members dealing with a stressful process. A compassionate, professional approach wins deals here.
Corrugated plastic signs at intersections that say 'We Buy Houses Cash — Call [number].' Illegal in some jurisdictions, but extremely effective where allowed. Cost per lead is very low. The calls you get are often highly motivated sellers.
💡 Pro tip: Check local ordinances first. In many cities, bandit signs are technically prohibited but enforcement is minimal. Know your risk tolerance.
Build relationships with agents who specialize in fixer-uppers, estate sales, and REO (bank-owned) properties. When they have a listing coming that will appeal to investors, they'll call you before it hits the MLS. Give them repeat business and they become a reliable deal source.
💡 Pro tip: Ask agents specifically: 'Do you have anything coming up that isn't listed yet?' This question alone has gotten me six deals over the years.
Pull a list of motivated sellers (absentee owners, tax delinquent, etc.) and contact them directly by phone or text. Response rates are low, but the cost per deal can be among the lowest of any channel when you have a system. Requires consistency and thick skin.
💡 Pro tip: Check TCPA regulations before texting. Cold texting to cell phones has specific legal requirements — use a compliant platform.
Which Method Should You Start With?
If you have more time than money:
Start with Driving for Dollars. Zero cost, teaches you to recognize distress, and gets you into neighborhoods you'll be buying in. Supplement with probate research at your county courthouse.
If you have more money than time:
Start with direct mail or a cold-calling service. Scale what works and cut what doesn't after 90 days. Budget $1,500–$3,000/month minimum to get consistent lead flow.
The Follow-Up System That Closes Deals
Most deals don't close on the first contact. The average motivated seller is contacted 5–7 times before they're ready to sell. You need a simple CRM to track every lead.
When someone calls, collect: name, address, reason for selling, timeline, condition of property, and what they need to feel good about the sale (price vs. speed vs. certainty). Then follow up on a consistent schedule — 2 weeks, 1 month, 3 months — until they sell to you or someone else.
📞 The one question that unlocks more deals
At the end of every seller call, ask: "Do you know anyone else in the area who might be thinking of selling?" Referrals from motivated sellers are the highest-quality leads you'll ever get.
Jake Martinez
Fix-and-Flip Investor · 890 posts · REICommunity Contributor
Jake has flipped 47 properties across Texas and Arizona since 2018. He runs a team of two acquisition managers and does 12–15 flips per year. His average profit per flip is $38,000.
Join the conversation
74 investors are already discussing this article. Share your experience or ask a question — free members get full access.